|
Post by King V on Mar 10, 2016 12:51:24 GMT -8
 "Homu, homu... I'm not sure why you're accusing me of such a thing, but I accept your challenge. Come at me!" |
|
|
Post by John Dark Souls on Mar 10, 2016 13:15:17 GMT -8
 "*deep breath* Okay then... At first I will start from most important thing. The murder weapon. What do you think was used as the murder weapon Sova-san. Yes, it is exactly that same cinder block that was used in order to knock out Reiten-san in the Dining Hall. Sova-san, you were the first person who have seize it and I have witnessed you taking it first-hand. Yes, I am talking about that time when I witnessed you taking the cinder block out of Boiler Room while humming some strange catchy tune about something starting to look a lot like something. After that I confronted you about it in Main Hall and when you told me to follow you I complied and then saw you knock out Reiten-san in front of me with that cinder block and throw it aside. After that you called everyone and I got knocked out so I'm not sure what happened exactly meanwhile but when I woke up, the cinder block was gone from the Dining Hall and you along with it and the cinder block isn't there right now. But shortly after you returned to Dining Hall and reported to Shion-san that you couldn't find Youmu-san meaning that you were sent to look for her. But not finding her is a lie. You did find Youmu-san. And after finding her, you called her out to Observatory and murdered her using that same cinder block that you used to knock Reiten-san out!" |
|
|
Post by King V on Mar 10, 2016 13:20:47 GMT -8
 "I'm not sure what you're going on about here... A-chan. Yes, you are now A-chan. You claim you saw me here and there, but in the end all of that is just conjecture. Perhaps you could have seen wrongly or been mistaken in what you saw." "As for your other claim, I did not lure Youmu to the Observatory, I spent a great deal of time searching for her on the 2nd floor before coming back to report to Shion in the dining hall." |
|
|
Post by John Dark Souls on Mar 10, 2016 13:34:40 GMT -8
 "True, you might not have lured her out. But that doesn't rule out that you could have knocked her out and then carried Youmu-san up to the Observatory. You do not have anything to prove that you indeed searched only on 2nd floor for Youmu-san. You could've searched for her on 2nd floor only to fail to find her after which you decided to go to 3rd floor and found her in the Observatory when you thought it was a chance and murdered her there and then. Do you have anything at all to prove otherwise?" |
|
|
Post by King V on Mar 10, 2016 13:42:49 GMT -8
"Hmm... then, let me approach this from a different angle. Suppose I was the culprit and I murdered Youmu on the 3rd floor. How would I get back down to the Dining Hall unnoticed? Quite a few people were on the 2nd floor walking around at the time, I saw them while I was searching for Youmu. I even met Mirai in the library before I went back downstairs. Given that so many people were still on the 2nd floor, one of them would definitely have noticed if I had come down from the 3rd floor, yet nobody saw me coming down from the 3rd floor. Can you explain how I could've pulled this off if I was the culprit, A-chan?" |
|
|
Post by John Dark Souls on Mar 10, 2016 14:24:41 GMT -8
 "Oh, so there were people on the 2nd floor watching if somebody went to or from the 3rd floor at the time? Then how about we ask them who they saw coming up or down the 3rd floor? Maybe they will tell us a clue to who the culprit has been. Also, you only said nobody saw you "coming down" from 3rd floor. But what about going up it? As I thought. You cannot deny the fact that you were at the 3rd floor at some point between when you were asked to go look for Youmu-san and when you went to report your findings to Shion-san. And so as long as there is even a single way of coming down from 3rd floor without being noticed, you still could be the culprit of this case. In fact, some other girl mentioned the window in the attic having no dust on it'd windowsill as if it was opened and I just confirmed it to be true. You have no proof of yourself not using the window to get down from 3rd floor unnoticed." |
|
|
Post by King V on Mar 10, 2016 14:40:04 GMT -8
 "That's no good, A-chan." " Flume Bullet - You cannot make an accusation with clues that are not presented!" "If you're accusing me of going up to the 3rd floor, killing Youmu, and going back down to the 1st floor to talk to Shion, you must have the proper clues! If you have no clues that I could come down from the 3rd floor without being noticed by the people there, your accusation holds no ground whatsoever!" |
|
